I believe in the choke chains, and don't believe in the edible reinforcer method. Dogs learn and behave best if trained with social praise and affection--basic behavior management. Hard, with a family, but everyone does need to use the same training approach. Training does not generalize well to people not doing the training. Tex is right--consistency is critical.
And remember, Whirly----the dog has to be to your left when heeling!




